On Fathering

 “In the United States and Norway, several studies involving boys with behavioral problems arrived at the conclusions that... male children absolutely need their fathers in the first two years of their existence...A son who is familiar with the physical presence of his father is thus initially able to love his mother, and later in life, is able to desire women rather than fearing them or despising them...”

— Guy Corneau, Absent Fathers Lost Sons

  “Ironically, men are...expected to have a capacity for intimacy with their partners and their children. How in the world can a person who has cut himself off from his body and heart--and be admired for this by society--aspire to intimacy with anybody?”

— Guy Corneau, Absent Fathers Lost Sons

 Previous generations of theorists would often complain about the mother’s role, but This is from the work of John Bradshaw and Guy Corneau [see bibliography page] and is about the importance of fatherhood in the lives of children of both genders, and the transmission of male emotional and physical abandonment from one generation to another. The industrial revolution took fathers off the farm, out of the home, away from their children, and placed them in factories and offices. Once fathers would work the family farm with their sons, and now sons rarely see their fathers. Fathers arrive home after working one or two jobs, and often have little energy for their children, preferring to relax with a beer, the newspaper and television. Both girls and boys, generally, get much more exposure to the mother. Girls have a more available role model to imitate, identify with, and rebel against. Mother teaches her daughter the ways of women, and often has more time and investment to do so. The process is conveyed through the emotional bond that the child feels. A boy often has less of a model for gender identification. A father is often not present, or father can be present but too often indifferent, overly busy. Bradshaw says, “What you love is what you give time to…”, A child can sense that he/she isn’t ‘’worth’’ giving time to as an unworded conclusion about the father's apparent emotional absence. The girl child will have mother to identify with, but the boy's role model is too often indifferent or absent by work, divorce, stress, exhaustion, addictions, or other interests. No matter how loving mother is, she cannot teach her sons how to be men. She doesn’t have the right equipment. The essential bond with fathering is how a boy is attracted away from the attachment to, and domination by, mother into the world of men. It happens in stages, from a 5 yr old carrying daddy’s hammer, to an older boy doing projects with dad. Still older boys having exclusive plans with his father. There’s the mouthy adolescent corrected by dad, the teenager taught to drive, and the young man who makes dad proud with his college grades. Throughout, the father ideally wants to have a relationship with his son, has an investment in teaching his son, making the son feel worthy of his father’s time.

Without a father figure to teach and attract the son, the boy can be engulfed by mother, feel responsible for yet resentful of for mother’s unmet emotional needs, and remain in the guilty tug of war with mom, hating her for his bondage yet needing her constant attention and guarantee of her love. He might choose a spouse eventually, but he will bond with her like ‘’mother’’, transferring the same maternal expectations onto the next woman, acting like a boy and expecting to be mothered. The expected roles of ''the man of the house'' as leader, protector, provider, teacher, etc. are compromised since the wife is more like a parent to her husband. Many wives roll their eyes and refer to their husband and two children as her "three children".

Without an involved father, it is furthermore difficult for mother to demonstrate the standard for the future men in her daughter’s life. It is the father who teaches his daughter that she is lovable to men, that she is worth his protection, time and concern. When he is absent, a daughter senses that she is not worth caring about. The standard is now set for her likely poor future choices in men, who would also not be expected to care about her. "After all, if your own father can't be bothered...".

If the father takes an interest in what is important to his son, he makes his son's activity important by his attention. The son will learn to take an interest in his own activities, feeling worth and value. "If it matters to Dad, it matters to me. If it doesn't matter to Dad, it doesn't matter to me." In the younger years of a future husband and father, the emotional and/or physical absence of one’s own father is like the absence of an important vitamin from the diet. There may be plenty of food, but an important nutrient is missing. It's hard to identify. There's no feeling of wholeness or completeness. There's an unnamed but severe emptiness there. Emotionally, it is hard to measure ‘’nothing’’, sensed only by an absence. The absence may show up as a naive like quality, acting in life but with a lack of information, support, and/or an inner sense of self or ‘’manliness’’. John Bradshaw, in his lecture on toxic shame, asks, “How can you love yourself as a man if you’ve never been loved by a man, and how can you love a woman as a man if you don’t love yourself as a man?”.

 “The pitched battles that often boys and their mothers are because the sons are trying in every possible way to escape from maternal domination, trying to wrest their bodies away from their mothers, and trying to prove themselves as men. The fathers usually feel powerless to do anything but watch these hostilities from the sidelines, unaware that they themselves are largely responsible for those hostilities. These situations often indicate that the sons are repressing their gentler emotions and imitating the worst macho types our society has produced...like Rambo and his cohorts...just to prove they are ‘man enough’.”

— Guy Corneau, Absent Fathers, Lost Sons

There are the day to day interactions and "visiting" that might happen with a father in the home. A father's work week influence is conveyed by his participation in the routine from evening to morning, how his disposition expresses itself becomes part of the fabric of the world each child takes in. What happens when there's no father there?

Imagine the ten most crucial times in life when, above all else, a child needs the father to show up, to be the hero, to save the day, by being physically present original trauma is often less of the unresolved problem than the perceived failures of the life mentors obliged to protect us and to help us pick up the pieces afterwards.

With a 57% divorce rate, there is an abundance of children growing up without a father in the home, and an even greater number whose fathers are emotionally, as well as physically, uninvolved.

 “...the sense of limits and discipline imposed by the father will only be effective in the context of a loving relationship. In other contexts, this prevents empty imitating his father.”

— Guy Corneau, Absent Fathers, Lost Sons

My father and me at my cousin's wedding in 1966. He was 57, my age last year. I was 15 then, his age when his father killed himself. This is about the closest we ever were. Six years later, he was dead.

My father and me at my cousin's wedding in 1966. He was 57, my age last year. I was 15 then, his age when his father killed himself. This is about the closest we ever were. Six years later, he was dead.

My father with his hand on brother's shoulder. When Dad was 12, his older brother died at 15 of Three years later, my father's father killed himself. Dad was immediately sent off to boarding school by his mother.

My father with his hand on brother's shoulder. When Dad was 12, his older brother died at 15 of Three years later, my father's father killed himself. Dad was immediately sent off to boarding school by his mother.

My father long before I was born.

My father long before I was born.

Lacking a Father is like Lacking a Backbone

“The more fragile a man feels internally, the more likely he is to try building an outer shell to hide this fragility. The shell make take the form of bulging muscles or a bulging belly... By means of these outward compensations, lost sons miss their deep desire to be touched, their need to love and be loved. It is hard for them to face up to these feelings because the facing-up makes them feel vulnerable. The signature of a missing father is the fragile masculine identity of his sons.”

“Masculine Energy I believe that a forceful, penetrating, active energy is one of the foundations of masculine energy; a man who is out of touch with his impulses or unable to control them, never feels himself to be a man...he must sense the particular kind of energy that makes him essentially different from women.”

“An individual's psychological identity is based on his sense of his own spine that provides him with support from the inside. The father's absence results in the child's lack of negative father complex. An individual with a negative father complex does not feel himself structured from within. His ideas are confused; he has trouble setting himself goals, making choices, deciding what is good for him, and identifying his own needs. For him, everything gets mixed up; love and reason, sexual appetites and the simple need for affection. He sometimes has problems concentrating, and he is distracted by all sorts of insignificant details, and in severe cases, he has difficulty organizing his perceptions. Basically, he never feels sure about anything.”

“A father's emotional presence brings his is rooted in primitive energy and natural aggression. The father's presence provides the son access to this aggression. When the father is absent, the son cannot tap into his sex's inherent impulses. The son is subject to his mother's restrictions; she is likely to be less tolerant of his instinctive, aggressive behavior than his father might have been...”

— Guy Corneau, Absent Fathers, Lost Sons

“The steep rise in domestic violence since the 1960s directly parallels the decline in fatherhood in America. When fathers are in families, they are more likely to struggle for power and control over their wives and girlfriends. They compensate for failure to protect with dominance. My experience with thousands of court-ordered domestic violence offenders tells me that when fathers are more involved in the lives of their children, they are unlikely to hurt any woman...”

— Stephen Stosny, PhD. How to Improve Your Marriage Without Talking About It

DAD_SAM-180x295.jpeg

 Daddy Report Card

  1. TAKING CARE OF ME;

    1. TALKING WITH MOM ABOUT WHAT I NEED TO GROW;

    2. GIVING MONEY FOR CLOTHES, FOOD AND HOME;

    3. BEING AN IMPORTANT PART OF MY DAILY ROUTINE;

    4. MAKING THE NECESSARY, TOUGH, UNPOPULAR DECISIONS;

    5. MAKING SURE THAT I’M SAFE;

    6. NOT DRINKING TOO MUCH ALCOHOL OR ABUSING DRUGS;

  2. TEACHING ME ABOUT THE WORLD;

    1. TEACHING ME ABOUT MEAN PEOPLE;

    2. TEACHING ME ABOUT MAKING FRIENDS;

    3. TEACHING ME ABOUT MONEY;

    4. TEACHING ME HOW TO STICK UP FOR MYSELF;

    5. TEACHING ME HOW TO CONTROL MY TEMPER;

    6. TEACHING ME ABOUT TELLING THE TRUTH;

  3. BEING SOMEONE I CAN LOOK UP TO;

    1. MAKING THE BEST OF FAMILY RELATIONSHIPS;

    2. HELPING ME FEEL BETTER WHEN MY WORLD FALLS APART;

    3. TEACHING ME TO HAVE FAITH IN MYSELF;

    4. SHOWING ME THE RIGHT WAY TO ACT;

    5. CORRECTING MY MISTAKES IN A KIND AND GENTLE WAY;

    6. GIVING ME A GOOD EXAMPLE TO LIVE UP TO


Resources

David DeAngelo, On Being a Man, Video series, David DeAngelo.com

Bryan Bayer and Travis Decker, Authentic Man Program,

Guy Corneau, Absent Fatehrs, Lost Sons

Samuel Osherson, Finding Our Fathers

Jonathan Diamond, Fatherless Sons

Susan Forward, Men Who Hate Women, The Women Who Love Them

Bryn C. Collins, Emotional Unavailability

Elyce Wakerman, Father Loss [for daughters]

Beth Erickson, PhD., Longing for Dad [for daughters]

 “A young man's heart is wounded when he has no one to take him into the adventures his soul craves, no one to show him how to shoot a free throw or jump his bike or rock climb or use a power tool. This is how most young men experience fatherlessness. There is no man around who cares and who is strong enough to lead him into anything. His father might be physically present, but unavailable in every way, hiding behind a newspaper or spending hours at a computer while the young man sits and waits hours for the man who never comes. Much of the anger we see in young men comes from this experience, because he is ready and fired up but has no outlet, no place to go. So it comes out in anger. A young man's heart is wounded when he repeatedly fails. Of course, failure is part of learning and every cowboy gets thrown from his horse, so to speak. But there needs to be someone at his side to interpret the failures and setbacks, to urge him to get back on the horse.”

— McConnell and Eldredge, The Way of the Wild at Heart workbook